Get Project EstimateBook a consultation

guides

Custom software vs off-the-shelf: where the line actually is

The honest rule: if a standard product covers about 80 percent of your process, buy it. Build only when the remaining 20 percent is the part that earns the money — and count the cost of workarounds on both sides before deciding.

Outcomes

  • Packaged software wins on speed to value and vendor-funded improvement
  • Custom wins when your process is the competitive advantage
  • Per-seat licences penalise growth; build cost does not
  • Workarounds are a real cost — measure them in hours per week
  • Hybrid is common: keep finance packaged, build the operational layer

Problems this solves

Licence cost keeps rising while the real work stays in spreadsheets

A clear sign the product covers the generic part of the process and not the part that matters.

Configuration has become its own project

When a standard product needs constant consultant work, its total cost approaches a build without the ownership.

The product dictates the process

Fine for accounting; expensive when the process is how you compete.

Realistic timeline

Weeks 1–2

Document the process and score two or three products against it honestly.

Week 3

Price both routes over three years, including internal effort.

Week 4

Decide, and start the smallest useful first phase of whichever route wins.

Build or buy

Buy something existing when

  • The process is standard and widely solved
  • Time to value matters more than fit
  • You have no capacity to own software

Build custom when

  • The process is a competitive advantage
  • Integration between existing systems is the real problem
  • Licence plus workaround cost already exceeds a build

Most healthy answers are hybrid: buy the commodity systems and build the operational layer that joins them.

What moves the price

Per-seat licences over time

Compare three to five years including growth, not the first-year invoice.

Configuration and consultants

Recurring external configuration cost belongs in the comparison.

Workaround labour

Hours spent on manual steps the product cannot do are a real, measurable cost.

Where projects go wrong

Comparing a demo to a plan

Score both options against the same written process, not against a sales presentation.

Ignoring exit cost

Ask what leaving each option costs, including data export format and licence terms.

FAQ

Questions buyers ask

How do we measure workaround cost?+

Count the hours per week your team spends compensating for the tool, multiply by loaded cost, and compare over three years.

Is custom riskier?+

Only if scope is undefined. A documented specification and phased delivery remove most of the risk people associate with building.

You already have the idea. Let's define what comes next.

Available in 12 languages

custom software vs off the shelf